In 2012, Carrero appeared in Blue Lagoon: The Awakening on Lifetime.
Carrero made her Off-Broadway debut in Atlantic Theater Company's world premiere play, "What Rhymes with America in December 2012."
She appears in 20th Century Fox's upcoming thriller "The Devil's Due," out in January of 2014. Carrero will recur in the second season of FX's "The Americans" as a Sandinista freedom fighter. She was also cast in the ABC Family multi-camera comedy show, "Young & Hungry," co-starring Emily Osment.